Brown Mountain old growth forest

From Greenlivingpedia, a wiki on green living, building and energy

Revision as of 00:54, 2 December 2008 by Peter Campbell (Talk | contribs)
Jump to: navigation, search
Brown Mountain old growth forest and Errindundra National Park
Unprotected old growth Shining Gum at Brown Mountain
Unprotected old growth Shining Gum at Brown Mountain
Protest against the logging of Brown Mountain at the Victorian parliament
Protest against the logging of Brown Mountain at the Victorian parliament
Stump of Brown Mountain old growth tree logged in November 2008
Stump of Brown Mountain old growth tree logged in November 2008

The wonderful old growth forest of Brown Mountain in East Gippsland is now being logged. There are more than 50 trees over 300 years old in this area of forest, which is adjacent to Errinundra National Park.

The Labor Party pledged during the 2006 State election that:

In addition to the Goolengook Block, a Labor Government will immediately protect remaining significant stands of old growth forest currently available for timber harvesting by including them in the National Parks and reserves system.[1]

This Brumby Government has broken this promise. The bulldozers moved in late October 2008 and clear felling of the forest commenced.

It is worth noting that none of the forest areas specified for protection have actually been protected yet either, 2 years after the election. It seems that the Brumby government supports clearfelling old growth forest as "business as usual" despite the forests critical role in storing carbon (over 1000 tonnes per hectare) and providing water for the depleted Snowy River catchment.[2]

These forests also provide habitat for threatened species such as the Powerful Owl, the Spot Tailed Quoll, mainland Australia's largest marsupial carnivore, and the Long-footed Potoroo, Victoria's rarest marsupial.

The government has claimed it is delivering a 5,000 ha link between the Snowy and Errinundra National Parks, but including this area of Brown Mountain is a vital part of this link.


A brief history of Brown Mountain

East Gippsland's forests have been heavily clearfell logged now for 35 years. Logging of heritage listed National Estate forests commenced in 1989. Brown Mountain was targeted for logging . Protests in the forests eventually halted the logging there, but the remaining old growth forest was not all protected.

Brown Mountain was assessed and listed as an old growth National Estate area by the Commonwealth Heritage Commission in the 1980s, which means it has the same values as a National Park. The management of these areas were handed to the state government which promptly set about clearfelling them in 1989.

The protests on Brown Mountain against logging there attracted much media attention when 300 people were arrested and charged with entering the area being logged. A moratorium was put on the logging while the state govermenet carried out a "Prudent and Feasible Study" into alternatives to logging National Estate listed forests.

As compensation for the year-long moratorium, the Federal Government gave the State Government (Premier of the time - John Cain, Kay Setches was minister) $10 million. This was used to push new roads into the heart of the very areas being studied - in anticipation of the outcome. It was also used to carry out plantation trials in regrowth forests - part of the long-term agenda to convert publicly owned native forests into industrial tree farms.

Labor government response to concerns about the logging

When queried about this decision to destroy the old growth forest, the response from Premier Brumby’s office was "since VicForests have moved the contractors in, there nothing we can do".

Premier Brumby's office was called on this matter on 30 October 2008 and advised that nobody could assist over the telephone, and that the best way to raise concerns about the logging were to email the Premier at [email protected]

Old growth forest maps of Brown Mountain

DSE map illustrating unprotected Brown Mountain old growth, circled
DSE map illustrating unprotected Brown Mountain old growth, circled

Victoria's Department of Sustainability and Environment's (DSE) own maps show that the area of Brown Mountain forest in question is old growth forest, which proves that it should have been included in the forest areas announced for protection in 2006, and therefore should not be logged.

The Old Growth Forest Walk - Goongerah

Labor's 2006 National Parks and Biodiversity policy included a commitment to create the Old Growth Forest Walk - Goongerah in the area of Brown Mountain old growth forest now being logged. The location of this walk has been agreed with DSE verbally, and during two site visits at Brown Mountain that included several representatives from DSE and the community.

The promise to construct this walk at Brown Mountain has been broken by the Brumby Labor Government. If the entire area is logged as planned, there will be no old growth forest left to walk through.

One of the logging coupes has even been named "The Walk" by DSE, which is a cruel irony.

Details of logging

Brown Mountain old growth coupes – 840-502-0020 is currently being logged
Brown Mountain old growth coupes – 840-502-0020 is currently being logged

This area contains 3 highly contentious coupes (840-502-0015, 840-502-0019, 840-502-0020) that were only added to the logging schedule in July 2007. Coupe 840-502-0020 is the one currently being logged.

A total of 19 hectares has been allocated for logging.

As at December 2, 2008 about 10 hectares has been logged.

The logging activities are providing employment for 4 people for about 6 weeks.

Link to climate change

Brown mountain forest are among the most carbon dense forests in the world, storing in excess of 1,200 tonnes of carbon per hectare in the trees, biomass, soil and leaf litter.

Between 500 to 1000 tonnes per hectare of carbon is released when this forest is logged, including leaves, branches and tree tops which are burnt, and log residues which then rot.

Logging these specific Brown Mountain forests is therefore likely to result in around 10,000 tonnes of carbon emissions, none of which are accounted or paid for. The carbon emissions from logging this area alone are equivalent to an additional 2,500 cars on Victorian roads.

Minister's response to question in parliament confirms logging of old growth

On November 12, 2008, Sue Pennecuik (Greens MP) asked the following question of Environment Mininster Gavin Jennings in the Victorian Parliament:

"Will the minister confirm that three logging coupes at Brown Mountain in East Gippsland — numbers 840-502-15, 19 and 20 that are mapped by the Department of Sustainability and Environment as old-growth forest — have been approved for clear-felling this season, that one is almost fully logged, and that this is in contravention to the Labor Party’s 2006 commitment to protect the last significant stands of Victoria’s old-growth forests currently available for logging?"

Some of the the response from Gavin Jennings:

..."Is there activity currently being undertaken in East Gippsland that is a source of contention in relation to the appropriateness of it being allocated for harvesting activity and being subject to protest activity?’, I can confirm that that is absolutely happening."
"Subsequently the election commitment — which was that we would increase the reserve system within East Gippsland — at one level may have been interpreted to mean that there would be absolutely no logging in areas that may be seen to be old growth, but they are not mutually exclusive commitments. In fact the coupes in question continue to be in areas known as general management zones within the forest."[3]

Supplementary question

Ms PENNICUIK (Southern Metropolitan) — The minister and I might disagree on what is on the maps. One of these logging coupes has been named ‘The Walk’ by VicForests in reference to the local community’s marked and tracked tourist walk, which was also committed to by the Labor government as the ‘Old Growth Forest Walk — Goongerah’. How is this consistent with the current logging operation?

Some of the the response from Gavin Jennings:

Again, this may be an area of contention.— It is an area of contention where people purport that there had been an alignment of a walk that had been adopted by the various state agencies. Despite the fact that there are many passionate and committed people — and good on them for being passionate and committed to environmental outcomes and sustainability in this area and generally — there has been no formal adoption of any delineation of a walking track by government agencies or the government that will define how the commitment to those walks will be delivered on the ground.

VicForest's response

VicForests has attempted to defend the clear-fell logging of old-growth forest near Brown Mountain in East Gippsland. The East Gippsland manager of VicForests, Barry Vaughan, says "the area was not part of the State Government's election promise to protect more forests".

In doing so, VicForests is ignoring the commitment made in Labor policy to protect the last remaining stands of old growth forests in Victoria available for logging.[4]

Protest on the steps of the Victorian parliament, November 7, 2008


Video: Single massive log on truck

Filmed near Goongerah. Logs like this will come out of Brown Mountain forest and go the woodchip mill at Eden. Over 80 percent of what is logged in East Gippsland ends up as woodchips.

Video: Brown Mountain forest in peril

Video by Jill Redwood.

Video: Brown mountain forest and logging

See also

More information, photos and external links


  1. Labor protects last significant old growth stands, 17 November 2006 (PDF)
  2. Nothing natural about selection of which trees die, Adam Morton, The Age, November 10, 2008
  3. HANSARD: Timber industry: East Gippsland logging, Forest Letter Watch Blog
  4. VicForests defends Brown Mountain logging, ABC News, November 13, 2005
Personal tools